Back to news

A check-in with Lawyers for Climate Action

8 min read • Nov 20, 2026, 2:43:08 PM

When we last checked in with Lawyers for Climate Action back in March, Jess Palairet walked us through their High Court challenge to the Government's Emissions Reduction Plan and the buzz of hosting Aotearoa's first climate litigation conference. After that, the Government turned up the volume.

We sat down with Laura MacKay, Lawyers for Climate Action's energy specialist who has been stepping up as acting Executive Director, to hear how a small team of lawyers spent 2026 responding to a law that cancelled a court case, an imported gas terminal, and a steady stream of rollbacks, and what our community's giving made possible along the way.

Three years in reverse

To understand Lawyers for Climate Action's year, it helps to zoom out. Since 2023, the Government has unwound a long list of environmental and climate protections. A few of the big ones:

  • Clean Car Discount scrapped in December 2023, passed under urgency.
  • Agriculture taken out of the Emissions Trading Scheme in 2024, and in October 2025 the Government confirmed farm emissions won't be priced by 2030.
  • Significant Natural Areas requirements suspended for three years, and the freshwater rules, including Te Mana o te Wai, being rewritten.
  • The Fast-track Approvals Act, letting listed projects (including coal mines and seabed mining) go through a faster one-stop approvals process instead of the usual consenting.
  • The 2018 ban on new offshore oil and gas exploration reversed in July 2025, with the first new offshore permit since granted.
  • The 2050 methane target cut from 24–47% to 14–24%, passed under urgency in December 2025 with every stage in a single day, so no select committee or public submissions.
  • The requirement for ETS settings to line up with our Paris commitments removed, so they now only have to match domestic targets.
  • The 2037 ban on coal boilers for industrial heat set to be scrapped as part of the resource management overhaul.
  • A $200 million Gas Security Fund to co-invest in gas, and plans for a Government-led LNG import terminal.
  • A new law barring climate claims in tort, written to stop Mike Smith's case against Fonterra and other big emitters before it reached trial.

Meanwhile, the Government's own Emissions Reduction Plan shows an 84 million tonne gap to our 2030 Paris target, with no funded plan to close it.

Sheesh, that’s quite the setlist. Not a chart-topper among them.

As you can imagine, a huge chunk of Lawyers for Climate Action's capacity this year has gone into stopping things going backwards rather than pushing them forward. Here's what that looked like.

Parliament shuts down a court case

In a David vs Goliath battle, in 2019 iwi leader Mike Smith (Ngāpuhi, Ngāti Kahu) attempted to use the law to hold some of New Zealand’s largest companies accountable for the damage they were causing. It was a climate case against six companies - Fonterra, Genesis, Z Energy, NZ Steel and others - who collectively cause roughly a third of New Zealand’s climate pollution. In 2024 the Supreme Court had unanimously agreed that Mike Smith could take his case to trial. In May 2026 the Government announced it would legislate the claim away, retrospectively.

Lawyers for Climate Action moved fast to oppose this Bill. Alongside Mike Smith, the National Iwi Chairs Forum Pou Tikanga and youth coalition Climate Clinic Aotearoa, they took a complaint to the UN Special Rapporteur on human rights and climate change. They organised a joint letter from lawyers, academics and other organisations opposing the bill, set up an online submission hub to help people have their say, ran webinars to explain what was at stake, and backed media coverage throughout.

93% of submissions opposed it and the situation created international outcry. But the law passed anyway and came into force on 25 August. A sliver of hope: commitments to repeal it are already on the record. That’s one record that’s sure to get another spin.

The LNG gamble

In February the Government announced it would build an LNG import facility in Taranaki, with the $1Bn of cost for this new fossil fuel infrastructure spread across power users. In collaboration with other groups, Lawyers for Climate Action has been pushing back.

Rather than leading with climate, the campaign made its case on value for money, electricity prices and safety - questions many New Zealanders were already asking. Lawyers for Climate Action have focused on the questions of accountability and transparency, using tools such asOfficial Information Act requests, plus complaints to the Ombudsman and the Auditor-General.

For example, when Lawyers for Climate Action and the NZ Climate Foundation requested the consultant's report which the Government was relying on to justify its decision to proceed with LNG imports, it came back heavily redacted. After an Ombudsman investigation found in their favour, the full report was released. It showed LNG wouldn't materially bring down power prices, and that other options, from more gas storage to new geothermal, wind and solar, could keep the lights on in a dry year.

They've since gone back to the Ombudsman over the bidders' safety evaluations, which were withheld in full even as Taranaki residents raised concerns about a terminal sited close to homes, and the Government’s failure to release key information before the election. And together with many other organisations, they asked the Auditor-General to look into the whole process. The Auditor-General has held off on an inquiry for now but is keeping a close eye on it.

In late September, Cabinet hit pause on approving the LNG contract, and nothing has been signed since. Not quite the record deal the Government had in mind.

Using every tool at their disposal

While others campaign, Lawyers for Climate Action files the OIA requests and chases them up when they stall. They're now on their fourth Ombudsman complaint over transparency related to LNG. It's slow, unglamorous work, but every request pursued to the end makes transparency a little more normal and encourages departments to handle the next one properly. It also provides much needed information to the public about the Government’s approach to climate and allows groups like Lawyers for Climate Action to assess whether the Government is acting lawfully in relation to its climate obligations, and take further action if needed. This is not just in relation to LNG, but also new offshore oil and gas permits, allocations under the Gas Security Fund and domestic and international climate obligations (as a few examples).

Drawing the road back

Laura was clear-eyed about what comes next. The deeper energy transition reforms will need economists, data modellers and technical partners alongside the lawyers, and Lawyers for Climate Action is already working with groups like WWF on energy. She also reflected on a wider shift in the movement - talking about power bills and safety rather than abstract climate targets lands with more people, though they’re certainly holding on to the bigger systemic picture too. And legal wins only last when they're paired with public campaigning, good communications and proper guardrails on transparency and lobbying.

Whatever the coming months bring, Lawyers for Climate Action is ready on all fronts - holding decision-makers to account and pushing for law reform that eases the cost of living, while laying the groundwork for the energy transition and stronger climate adaptation.

The world is watching

New Zealand used to trade on its clean, green reputation. Lately, the world has been taking notes of a different kind.

On 29 September, Dutch environmental justice organisation Both ENDS lodged a complaint with the European Commission under the EU–New Zealand free trade agreement, the first on climate grounds under the EU's complaints process. It argues New Zealand has broken two promises in the agreement: not to weaken environmental protections to boost trade, and to effectively implement the Paris Agreement.

Much of the evidence reads like the list at the top of this post, and our own foreign ministry had reportedly warned that reopening offshore exploration could clash with our trade commitments. If the complaint goes all the way to a panel and a breach is found, trade benefits can be suspended. You can read Both ENDS' summary here.

What your giving did

Our grant was unrestricted, and Laura talked about how precious having flexibility from funders is. When the tort bill and the LNG terminal landed out of nowhere, Lawyers for Climate Action could change course quickly, without having to go back to funders for permission or to rewrite a project plan.

Lawyers for Climate Action has grown from a team of one to a team of three, with the most recent focus being a senior lawyer to lead their energy transition work. In a year that kept throwing so much at them, that extra capacity meant they could keep time even as the tempo kept changing. We're proud to be one of their backers.

Laura reminded us that these setbacks don't have to be permanent. The groundwork for going forward again is being laid right now, often in an OIA request or a draft bill that nobody sees.

A huge thank you to everyone in The Climatics community who gave. You were part of the crowd backing these lawyers right in a crucial time.

If you'd like to keep supporting Lawyers for Climate Action, you can learn more and donate here.

 

The Climatics